September 20, 2017

Like All Things, Cassel Too Must Pass

logoby Dan Snapp
[email protected]

Out here, they call it “Minnesota Nice”.

It’s the comment that sounds complimentary, but turns sour the more it ruminates in your skull. Depending on the source, it’s either a sincere belief people here are more kindly, or more passive aggressively, that every smile cloaks a dagger.

Matt Cassel is the recipient of the Oscar of backhanded compliments for quarterbacks: “Good game manager.”

After the Patriots’ huge win over the Jets Sunday – and let’s not understate this, it was enormous – “manager” has been the predominant description for Cassel’s role in the offense. Said Coach Belichick right after the game:

I thought Matt took care of the ball. It wasn’t perfect. He had some rough spots in there, but he did a good job making good decisions and didn’t put us in any bad situations, and made some good, positive plays by managing the game well.

The sentiment was echoed in every game story and pundit’s take thereafter, and the dreaded moniker settled in around Cassel’s shoulders: “Game manager.” It’s the descriptor to which no child aspires when tossing the ball around with his friends.

“Here’s Montana with the throw!”
“Here’s Elway with the bomb!”
“Here’s Hostetler with the handoff!”

It just doesn’t happen.

In context, it sounds a compliment, but it’s not much of one. It’s saying that within the minute parameters of what we allowed you to do, you soared. It’s saying, “Hey, you did great: you didn’t screw up.” It’s the soft bigotry of low expectations.

This commentary is admittedly unfair to Cassel, as he did indeed do all that was asked of  and expected of him. He is rightly praised for his performance. But something still gnaws at you.

The Pats won by two scores, but with something missing. The Jets bemoaned their missed opportunities, but the Patriots could claim their share. Four times in the red zone, they settled for three. That’s the kind of thing that can come back to haunt a team, like it did for the Vikings against Indianapolis Sunday.

Just as we knew last year that the Pats would have to count on the running game somewhere down the line, so too do we know that at some point, Matt Cassel’s going to have to win a game with his arm.

Have no doubt, the scenario will occur: the Pats down 10 with eight minutes to go in the fourth, against a D more stalwart than what the Jets had to offer. And that defense will know Cassel will be throwing. The original game plan long dismissed, the clock the enemy, and everything riding on whether Cassel can be more than just a manager.

That’s the scenario Tom Brady faced in his third game as a starter. Down two scores against the Chargers, Brady engineered two fourth-quarter scores, with Adam Vinatieri kicking the game-winning field goal in overtime. It was the first moment many of us thought we might have something more than just a stopgap in Brady. 

As monumental as Brady’s accomplishments were in 2001, in hindsight he had it easy: he didn’t have to replace Tom Brady.

There’s much to like in Cassel’s manner. He’s poised and confident, with a strong arm and seemingly a good understanding of the offense. From what we can tell, it looks like he’s proficient going through his checkdowns. It’s obvious he doesn’t have Brady’s pocket presence (a gift Brady shares with very few QBs), nor Brady’s uncanny ability to hit his receivers in stride.

Belichick noted that the Jets took away Randy Moss with help over the top most of the day, so it’s to Cassel’s credit he didn’t try to force anything there. This also left CBS cameras hovering on Moss’s face on the sideline, praying for a scowl or a pout. Cassel will have to find a way to get to Moss at some point. Man cannot live by dumpoff alone.

Arguably, recognition is Brady’s greatest asset: of  the defense at pre-snap, of the adjustments at the snap, and of receivers changing routes midstream. In the first two games, Moss had two notable instances of changing his route when reading an opportunity for something bigger; in both instances, Cassel was right there with him. Cassel was 1-for-2 in executing on those bombs, but 2-for-2 in the recognition. This gives room for hope.

When the time comes, a game situation will dictate that Cassel run the offense, not just manage it. And he’ll have the chance to break free of the maxim that threatens to define his career.

Let’s just hope he can manage that.


  1. I don’t think ‘good game manager’ is such a bad thing – half the starting QBs in the league aspire to that label.

    I’d rather have a good game manager than a gunslinger or a cerebral statue.

  2. “I’d rather have a good game manager than a gunslinger or a cerebral statue.”

    Good point.

  3. I just picture a guy with a nametag running around saying things like “I can take you at this register, maddam.”

  4. Chris Warner says:

    I think with their schedule against some teams that lack a pass rush, Cassel will start to open it up before the second half of the season. I’m a big believer in throwing a bomb once in a while: If it hits, great; if not, at least you’ve got the defense thinking about it.

    My God, when will Belichick and McDaniels come to their senses and consult us as online offensive coordinators? We’d work for SO little!

  5. Hey Dan,
    Well I guess the pundits didn’t see that drive Cassel engineered when the game was on the line. The one that came after Favre threw that TD that got the Jets and the fans all jacked up. That drive reminded me of the one Brady engineered in the last seconds of the Super Bowl vs. the Rams. Up to that point Brady was just a “manager” (I can still hear Madden saying take a knee, take a knee this is crazy only 30 seconds to go) and it was all about Coach BB. But that drive was Brady’s defining moment in his career. This one could be just as big for Cassel.

  6. It’s all premature, and alarmist, I suppose. They ARE 2-0 after all.

    I see a cautionary tale in the Vikings. I think they gambled they can win on defense and a superior running game while waiting for Tarvaris Jackson to develop into more than a game manager. But guys like Pat Williams can’t afford to wait; there’s only a brief window that their stellar D-line (Williams, Kevin Williams, Jared Allen and Ray Edwards) stays together before retirement or free agency peels away at it.

    Every year is a unique opportunity to win, with a unique grouping of players that won’t exist the following year. The loss of Brady has us reevaluating the realistic goals, but it doesn’t change the end goal for the team. So it’s recalibrating the variables to determine what would make the Super Bowl realistic. To get to the Super Bowl, Cassel will have to be more than a manager.

    Again, way too premature.

  7. Tarvaris Jackson has started 14 NFL games in his 3 seasons and the Vikings’s coaches act like he’s garbage. Being that Bill Belichick is no Brad Childress, my guess is that by the time *he’s* at start 14, Matt Cassel won’t be “managing” for FGs. If the Patriot coaches think that they have to “Jacksonize” him to win games, they will replace him long before week 15, since they, too, know that a team can’t consistently win that way.

    I think that the coaches believed that defensively, they could keep the Jet offense to a minimum, and thus simply scoring on more than 50% of the possessions –either by FG or TD–would be enough. Thus the game plan. It might be more of the same vs. Miami, although to be honest, I have no idea if Miami’s offense is any good.

    But I have little doubt that if the team thinks that they have to throw to win, they will throw. And if they don’t think Cassel is up to the task, then he wont be the thrower.

    So maybe we see a bit more of the same in Week 3. Then, after the bye, we see a bit more air.

  8. Another good one Dan (not just being ‘Merrimack Valley Nice’ here!); was hoping someone would touch on the “Game Manager” epithet.

    The comparisons with Brady in ’01 are inevitable, but are they appropriate? The low expectations associated with Brady’s debut had as much to do with the overall offensive talent level as much as his own inexperience. Seven years later the Patriots are so loaded that even Brady’s loss isn’t a death sentence: Cassel has three Pro Bowlers blocking for him, complementary receivers and a versatile RB corps that runs 5 deep. So while this year’s unit so far isn’t lighting up the scoreboard and probably won’t average 38 PPG, if they find themselves in the scenario Dan suggested its healthy to believe they can get the job done.

  9. Garbage in, garbage out . . .

    Jackson’s out; Frerotte’s in (

  10. Hi, I found your blog on this new directory of WordPress Blogs at I dont know how your blog came up, must have been a typo, i duno. Anyways, I just clicked it and here I am. Your blog looks good. Have a nice day. James.

Leave a Reply